, , ,

How to Choose an EMDR Therapist

Notes from an EMDRIA-Approved Consultant on what actually distinguishes good EMDR work How to Choose an EMDR Therapist Part of my work is not therapy at all. It is consultation — sitting with other licensed clinicians, while they learn to do EMDR well. As an EMDRIA-Approved Consultant, I provide the consultation hours therapists are required…


Notes from an EMDRIA-Approved Consultant on what actually distinguishes good EMDR work


How to Choose an EMDR Therapist

Part of my work is not therapy at all. It is consultation — sitting with other licensed clinicians, while they learn to do EMDR well.

As an EMDRIA-Approved Consultant, I provide the consultation hours therapists are required to complete on their way to becoming an EMDRIA Certified Therapist. I listen to how they describe their cases. I ask what they did when a client’s processing stalled. I review their actual clinical work, and at the end of that process, if the work warrants it, I write the letter of recommendation that goes to EMDRIA. EMDRIA grants the credential; my role is to evaluate whether the clinician is ready for it.

Which means I have spent a lot of hours watching the specific places EMDR goes right and goes wrong.

I am writing this because most of the advice available to someone searching for an EMDR therapist is not wrong so much as I feel like it is somewhat useless to the prospective client. “Look for someone you feel comfortable with.” True, and not actionable. “Make sure they’re trained in EMDR.” Also true, and far weaker protection than it sounds.

Here is what I would want you to know.


“EMDR trained” and “EMDR certified” are not the same thing

This is the single most useful distinction in the whole field, and almost nobody outside of it knows it exists.

EMDRIA — the EMDR International Association, the body that sets standards in the United States — uses both phrases, and they mean different things. (Before I go further, I urge you strongly to only use therapists trained by EMDRIA-Approved trainers because EMDRIA spends a lot of time in oversight of its practitioners.)

An EMDRIA Trained Therapist has completed an EMDRIA-Approved Basic Training. By EMDRIA’s published minimums, that training includes 20 hours of instructional content, 20 hours of supervised practicum, and 10 hours of consultation. That is a real credential and a real floor. It is also, by design, an introduction. Read this last sentence again: It is also, by design, an introduction.

An EMDRIA Certified Therapist has done considerably more. Certification requires full licensure for independent practice, completion of basic training, additional consultation hours with an approved consultant, a documented volume of clinical EMDR work, and ongoing EMDR-specific continuing education.

A therapist who finished a weekend-plus-weekend basic training in 2019 and has used EMDR six times since can accurately say they are “trained in EMDR.” A therapist who has completed certification cannot say so without having done the hours and ongoing continuing education.

Neither of these is a reason to rule someone out. Some of the best EMDR clinicians I have consulted with were not yet certified, and some were deliberately never going to pursue it. Certification is a floor, not a ceiling, and plenty of excellent therapists skip it for reasons that have nothing to do with skill. I want to be clear, again, that some of the best EMDR clinicians I have consulted with were not certified yet.

But the distinction gives you a real question to ask, and the answer tells you something.


Why this matters more in EMDR than in some other therapies

There is a reasonable objection here: does it actually matter how well-trained the clinician is, if the protocol works?

It appears to matter in research and, anecdotally, in my practice I can wholeheartedly say “it matters!”

A meta-analysis by Lee and Cuijpers (2013) examined the eye movement component of EMDR across both clinical and laboratory studies. Two findings are relevant here. The first is that the eye movements themselves contributed a measurable additive effect — moderate in clinical studies (d = 0.41) and larger in laboratory studies (d = 0.74). The second, and the one I think about more, is that treatment fidelity moderated the outcomes in the clinical studies. How closely the therapist adhered to the protocol predicted how well it worked.

That is an uncomfortable finding for a field that markets itself on the strength of the protocol. It means the protocol is not self-executing. Someone has to run it correctly, and the degree to which they do is visible in the results.

This is, more or less, the entire reason the consultation requirement exists. And further to that, there is the basic, 8-phase protocol but there are also so many more.


The five questions I would actually ask

If were going to help a family member or a friend find an EMDR therapist, these are the questions I would tell them to ask. None of them require you to know anything about EMDR. All of them produce answers that distinguish between clinicians.

1. “Are you EMDRIA certified, or EMDR trained?”

You now know the difference. What you are listening for is not the answer so much as the ease of it. A clinician who is comfortable with their own training history will tell you plainly: “I’m trained but not certified, I completed basic training in 2021 and I’ve done about forty EMDR courses of treatment since.” That is a good answer.

The answer that should give you pause is a vague one. “I use EMDR techniques.” “I’m EMDR informed.” “I’ve been doing this a long time.” Those phrases are doing work, and the work they are doing is obscuring something.

2. “How long do you usually spend before we start reprocessing?”

EMDR has eight phases. The reprocessing — the part people have seen in videos, with the eye movements — is phase four. The three phases before it are history-taking, treatment planning, and preparation: building the relationship, assessing stability, teaching the client how to regulate enough to tolerate what reprocessing will stir up.

There is no correct number of sessions. For a single-incident trauma in an otherwise stable adult, preparation might take two sessions. For someone with complex developmental trauma, dissociation, and a thin support system, it might take two months or more. I’ve worked with clients who told me they were put into Phase 4 at the first meeting with a therapist and had an awful reaction. My response is, “I’m sorry that happened to you, but it will not happen here.”

What you want to hear is that the answer depends on you. A clinician who says “we’ll start reprocessing in session three” regardless of who is sitting in front of them is running a schedule, not a treatment plan. In my consultation work, rushing phase two is the single most common error I see, and it is the one most likely to end with a client feeling worse and concluding EMDR does not work for them. In fact, this can do more harm to some clients. Think about if you are seeking psychotherapy and EMDR for shame-based belief systems about yourself and you are the client I just described. Not only might you feel like EMDR doesn’t work for you but you might even feel more shame and further defective beliefs.

3. “What do you do when processing gets stuck?”

Processing stalls. A client loops on the same image, the distress will not come down, the body goes numb and nothing moves. This is normal and expected, and standard EMDR has a set of specific interventions for it — the cognitive interweave, changes to the mechanics of the bilateral stimulation, returning to the target, going back to preparation work. Maybe even considering EMDR 2.0, the Flash Technique, maybe 4-Blinks.

You are not evaluating the technical accuracy of the answer. You are listening for whether there is an answer. A therapist who has worked through enough stuck processing will have something concrete to say. A therapist who has mostly done EMDR with straightforward presentations may say something like “that doesn’t usually happen” — which is itself informative.

4. “Do you screen for dissociation before starting?”

This is the question I care most about, and the one almost nobody asks.

Dissociation — losing time, feeling unreal, watching yourself from outside, parts of yourself that seem to operate independently — changes how EMDR should be delivered. It does not rule EMDR out. It means preparation needs to be longer, stability work needs to come first, and reprocessing needs to be paced differently.

Screening for it is standard practice. A clinician who assesses it at intake will say so immediately. One who does not will often not understand why you are asking. If you get a gut reaction they don’t know what you are talking about, please kindly say thank you and find another clinician.

In my practice all clients sit with me and we go through, at a minimum, the DES-II and talk about the answers, usually in depth. In more severe cases, we may even do further, more advanced assessment.

5. “Have you worked with what I’m bringing you?”

Not “have you treated PTSD” — nearly everyone will say yes. Something more specific. Combat exposure. Childhood sexual abuse. Medical trauma. A car accident. Intimate partner violence. Moral injury in healthcare work. Religious trauma. The thing you actually carry.

Specific experience matters, and a clinician who has not worked much with your presentation but is honest about it and willing to consult is often a better bet than one who claims comfort with everything.

I have not worked with every possible reasons someone may be reaching out for care. I am a firm believer EMDR, when properly utilized, can indeed work at reducing symptoms of most presenting issues and concerns, but I also understand my limitations, and any therapist you consult with for potential care must be honest about their limitations too.


A note on the credentials themselves, since they are confusing

EMDRIA’s credential structure is genuinely hard to parse from the outside, and the terms get used loosely. Here is the actual ladder:

EMDRIA Trained Therapist — completed an EMDRIA-Approved Basic Training.

EMDRIA Certified Therapist — fully licensed for independent practice, completed basic training in full, and completed EMDRIA’s certification requirements, which include additional consultation with an approved consultant and documented clinical EMDR experience.

EMDRIA Approved Consultant-in-Training — a Certified Therapist who has declared their intent to pursue the consultant credential and is receiving consultation-of-consultation from an Approved Consultant.

EMDRIA Approved Consultant — a Certified Therapist with at least three years of EMDR experience following basic training, a minimum of 300 clinical sessions in which EMDR was used, at least 20 hours of consultation-of-consultation, and a recommendation from one or more consultants. Consultants complete 12 hours of EMDR continuing education every two years. This is my credential. The role, as EMDRIA frames it, has three parts: educator, motivator, and evaluator — sharing knowledge, building a consultee’s confidence, and assessing readiness.

EMDRIA Approved Trainer — a separate credential, held by clinicians who are already both Certified and Approved Consultants, and who have gone through EMDRIA’s additional application process to teach EMDR Basic Training itself.

Consultant and Trainer are often confused, including by therapists. They are different roles. A Trainer delivers the basic training course. A Consultant provides the ongoing consultation that comes after it, and evaluates readiness for certification. I am a Consultant, not a Trainer.


What the credentials do not tell you

I want to be careful here, because I have just spent a thousand words on credentials and I do not want to leave you with the impression that they are the whole story.

They are not. The research on psychotherapy outcomes is fairly consistent that the relationship between client and therapist carries real predictive weight, and no credential measures that. I have consulted with certified clinicians whose technical protocol adherence was excellent and whose clients did not get better, because something in the room was not working. I have consulted with newer clinicians whose instincts were extraordinary.

Credentials tell you that someone has done the hours. They do not tell you that this particular person is right for you.

What I would suggest: use the questions above to screen out clinicians who are operating outside their competence, and then pay attention to how the first two or three sessions feel. Do you feel like this person can tolerate what you are about to tell them? Do they slow down when you get overwhelmed, or push through? When you say something difficult, does the room get safer or tighter?

That last one is not measurable and it is not on anyone’s credential. It is also, in my experience, the thing that decides.


If you are looking in Florida, Maryland, Virginia, or Washington DC

I am licensed in Florida, Maryland, Virginia, and the District of Columbia and Vermont (tele). I see clients in person in Fort Lauderdale and work remotely across all jurisdictions. I am an EMDRIA Certified Therapist, an EMDRIA-Approved Consultant, and a Board-Certified Diplomate in Clinical Social Work.

If you have read this far and have questions about whether EMDR is a reasonable fit for what you are carrying, you are welcome to reach out and ask. I would rather have a frank conversation about fit than book someone who should be working with somebody else.

Contact Link


References

Lee, C. W., & Cuijpers, P. (2013). A meta-analysis of the contribution of eye movements in processing emotional memories. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 44(2), 231–239. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbtep.2012.11.001

Rasines-Laudes, P., & Serrano-Pintado, I. (2023). Efficacy of EMDR in anxiety disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Psicothema, 35(4), 385–396. https://doi.org/10.7334/psicothema2022.309

Credential requirements described above are drawn from EMDRIA’s published standards and glossary. Requirements change; verify current standards directly with EMDRIA.